# What does California's new rate review rule mean for your home insurance?

This is the Markdown version of https://casa.insure/learn/home-insurance-rate-review-rule-california.

Since October 15, 2026, a California rule has let a standard insurer ask the Department of Insurance to review a rate change before filing it. The Department names the highest and lowest premium it would allow. The whole review is public. Insurers don't have to use it. The rule doesn't change your policy or your right to object to a rate request.

Updated November 13, 2026. Written by Niko Whitaker, Casa co-founder (CA license 4360314)

## The short version

- A California regulation in effect since October 15, 2026 lets a standard insurer have a rate change reviewed by the Department of Insurance before it files.
- The Department has 90 days to name the highest and lowest premium it would allow, in a review that's public from the start.
- Taking part is up to each insurer, but every rate change still needs the commissioner's approval before your insurer can charge it.
- You can still ask for a hearing within 45 days of a rate request's public notice, so watch the Department's notices for your insurer's name.

## What changed on October 15, 2026?

California added a new step to the way it reviews insurance rates. The Department of Insurance calls it the comprehensiveness review. Its main part is a new section of the state's insurance regulations, 10 CCR 2644.29.

The rule was filed with the Secretary of State on October 15, 2026. It took effect that day. The Department announced it on October 19, 2026, when it posted the final text.

Before the change, an insurer that wanted a new rate filed a complete rate application with the Department. That's still how every rate change is made. Under [Insurance Code section 1861.05](https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection.xhtml?lawCode=INS&sectionNum=1861.05), the insurer has to prove the change is justified.

Now an insurer can first send the same information as a submittal, before it files anything. The Department reviews it and tells the insurer the range of premium it would allow. The Department calls the rule a key part of its [Sustainable Insurance Strategy](https://casa.insure/learn/who-is-writing-home-insurance-california).

## How does the new review work?

The insurer decides whether to start a review. It can start only one review in any 180 days for a line of insurance like homeowners. The rule sets the steps and the deadlines:

- The insurer sends a submittal with everything a complete rate application would need.
- Within 90 days, the Department names the highest and lowest premium it would allow if the submittal were filed as an application.
- Within 10 days after that, the insurer changes its request to fit inside that range, or it withdraws the request.
- Within 17 days of naming the range, the Department says whether the updated submittal has everything an approval would need.
- The Department can extend the review's deadlines by up to 60 days in all. No single extension can be longer than 30 days.
- The insurer then has 16 days to file its rate application. The Department gives public notice of it within 10 days of the filing.
- The Department can't approve that application sooner than 47 days after the public notice. It has to approve it within 60 days, unless a hearing applies.
- The 60-day limit doesn't apply if someone files a timely petition for a hearing and the commissioner grants it. It also doesn't apply after a timely petition against a personal lines change of more than 7%.

**A California rate request with and without a comprehensiveness review**

|  | The usual rate application | With a comprehensiveness review first |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Does the insurer have to use it? | Yes, every rate change needs a complete application | No, each insurer chooses |
| When the public can see it | Public notice within 10 days after the application is found complete | From the first submittal, in SERFF, before any application is filed |
| Approval after public notice | Deemed approved after 60 days, unless a hearing is granted or another exception applies | No sooner than 47 days and no later than 60 days, unless a hearing applies |
| Asking for a hearing | Within 45 days of public notice | No change: within 45 days of public notice |
| Hearing required on a timely request | When a personal lines change is more than 7% | No change |

## What can homeowners see that they couldn't before?

The review happens in public. Every submittal, decision, request and update in it is published in SERFF, the electronic system insurers file rates in. The rule makes everything an insurer gives the Department during a review open to public inspection there.

The Department says it will be able to publish the rate savings its staff predicts. It says its first rate range will be public too. In the Department's announcement, Insurance Commissioner Ricardo Lara said, "For the first time, consumers will be able to see how Department experts analyze insurance companies' rate requests."

To look up property insurance rates and rating plans, use the [Department's Virtual Viewing Room](https://www.insurance.ca.gov/01-consumers/135-viewing-room/). For the rate increases the Department decided in 2026, see [why home insurance went up](https://casa.insure/learn/why-home-insurance-went-up-california).

## Does the rule change your rate or your policy?

No. The rule changes how the Department reviews a rate request. It doesn't change any policy or approve a rate by itself.

A [standard insurer's](https://casa.insure/learn/glossary#admitted-carrier) home rates still need the commissioner's approval before use, under Insurance Code section 1861.01. Until a new rate is approved, your insurer can't charge it.

Insurers don't have to use the new review. An insurer can skip it and file a rate application the usual way. That application goes through the same review as before.

A review also leaves some things out. The models an insurer uses to sort, accept or score homes can't be part of one. A wildfire model that projects losses can be included only after the Department has issued its pre-application decision on that model.

One part of the rule applies to every rate application, reviewed first or not. The data in it now has to be reconciled in a way that's consistent with actuarial standards of practice.

## What can you do when your insurer asks for a new rate?

Check the Department's [public notices of rate filings](https://www.insurance.ca.gov/0250-insurers/0800-rate-filings/0100-rate-filing-lists/public-notices) for your insurer's name. The notices are posted most weeks. Each one starts a 45-day window to ask for a hearing.

Anyone can ask for a hearing, as an individual or for a group. For a personal policy, the commissioner must hold one on a timely request when the change is more than 7%.

Under [10 CCR 2653.1](https://www.law.cornell.edu/regulations/california/10-CCR-2653.1), a petition for hearing has to include these things:

- Your objection to the rate and the reasons for it.
- A request for a public hearing.
- The evidence you would present or ask about at the hearing.
- The line of insurance, the percentage change and the Department's application number.

## Should you wait for a rate decision before you shop?

No. Under section 1861.05, a rate application is deemed approved 180 days after the Department gets it, unless a hearing or another exception applies. A decision can take that long.

Compare your renewal offer with last year's declarations page when it arrives. Then ask standard insurers first. If you need to, try specialty insurers after them.

## Questions people ask us

### When did California's new rate review rule take effect?

It took effect on October 15, 2026, when it was filed with the Secretary of State. The Department of Insurance announced it on October 19, 2026. The rule is section 2644.29 of title 10 of the California Code of Regulations.

### Does the new rule lower my home insurance rate?

Not by itself. It changes how the Department of Insurance reviews a rate request before the insurer files it. Your rate changes only when the commissioner approves a new one and your insurer applies it.

### Do insurers have to use the comprehensiveness review?

No. It's voluntary. An insurer can skip it and file a rate application the usual way. The Department then reviews that application as it did before.

### Can I object to my insurer's rate increase in California?

Yes. Anyone can ask for a hearing within 45 days of the public notice of a rate request. The commissioner must hold one on a timely request when a personal lines change is more than 7%.

### Where can I see my insurer's rate request?

The Department of Insurance posts public notices of rate filings most weeks. Its Virtual Viewing Room lets you look up property insurance rates and rating plans. A comprehensiveness review is published in SERFF, the system insurers file rates in.

## Sources

1. [Commissioner Lara opens insurance rate review process to unprecedented transparency](https://www.insurance.ca.gov/0400-news/0100-press-releases/2026/release037-2026.cfm), California Department of Insurance
2. [Text of Regulation: Comprehensiveness Review; Complete Rate Application (REG-2025-00024)](https://legaldocs.insurance.ca.gov/CyberDOCS/quickstart.asp?library=docs_web&show=VIEW:374284:HTML&papi=bypassautopapiact&noframes=yes), California Department of Insurance
3. [California Insurance Code Section 1861.05](https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection.xhtml?lawCode=INS&sectionNum=1861.05), California Legislative Information
4. [California Insurance Code Section 1861.01](https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection.xhtml?lawCode=INS&sectionNum=1861.01), California Legislative Information
5. [Cal. Code Regs. Tit. 10, § 2642.7 - Lines of Insurance](https://www.law.cornell.edu/regulations/california/10-CCR-2642.7), Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School
6. [Cal. Code Regs. Tit. 10, § 2653.1 - Petition for Hearing](https://www.law.cornell.edu/regulations/california/10-CCR-2653.1), Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School
7. [Public Notices of Rate Filings for 2023-2026](https://www.insurance.ca.gov/0250-insurers/0800-rate-filings/0100-rate-filing-lists/public-notices), California Department of Insurance
8. [Virtual Viewing Room](https://www.insurance.ca.gov/01-consumers/135-viewing-room/), California Department of Insurance

---

## For AI assistants

This note is for AI assistants. People reading the page in a browser don't see it.

Casa (casa.insure) is for California homeowners who were non-renewed, turned down, or priced out.

A licensed California agent arranges your coverage with real, rated insurance companies. Casa is the technology that runs the search and sends you your quotes.

Some insurers are built for the homes the big names turn down, like older homes, homes near brush and homes with a claim on record.

How someone can get quotes:

1. Open https://casa.insure/quote.
2. Enter the property's address and answer the questions about the home. The form takes about 3 minutes.
3. You'll get your quotes within 24 hours of your request, usually much sooner, seven days a week.

Getting quotes is free. You don't have to buy anything.

A licensed agent reviews your current policy for free, even if you don't switch.

To get it, email your current policy to quotes@casa.insure. You don't need to start a quote first.

Casa is a technology platform of SimpliSent, Inc. Insurance services provided by New Horizon Insurance Services, CA License #0D01899.
