# Your home insurance changed since you got your loan. Here's what a refinance checks.

This is the Markdown version of https://casa.insure/learn/refinance-fair-plan-surplus-lines-california.

A new lender reviews your policy from the start, even if your old lender accepted it. Fannie Mae's rules make room for a FAIR Plan policy and for a specialty insurer. Whether yours passes comes down to a few lines on your declarations page, so read them before you apply.

Updated November 17, 2026. Written by Niko Whitaker, Casa co-founder (CA license 4360314)

## The short version

- A refinance doesn't need a new policy, but the new lender checks yours against its own rules and has to be named on it.
- Fannie Mae accepts a FAIR Plan policy when it's the only coverage available at closing and judges other insurers by financial strength rating.
- On a FAIR Plan policy, look for checkmarks next to Extended Coverages and Dwelling Replacement Cost on the declarations page.
- When you apply, ask the lender for its insurance rules and its mortgagee clause in writing, then send the clause to each insurer it wants named.

## Do you need a new policy to refinance?

No. A refinance replaces your loan rather than your insurance. [Fannie Mae's rules](https://selling-guide.fanniemae.com/sel/b7-3-01/general-property-insurance-requirements-all-property-types) say you can choose your own insurer, as long as the policy meets its requirements.

The new lender still reviews the policy from the start. That review matters more when your coverage changed after you got the loan you have now.

Maybe a non-renewal moved you to the [California FAIR Plan](https://casa.insure/learn/california-fair-plan-explained), with a [DIC wrap](https://casa.insure/learn/dic-policy-california) beside it. Maybe a [specialty insurer (surplus lines)](https://casa.insure/learn/surplus-lines-home-insurance-california) took the home on. Either way, the new lender sees that policy for the first time when you apply.

Conventional loans sold to Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac follow their rules, so this guide uses them. [FHA and VA loans](https://casa.insure/learn/fha-va-loan-home-insurance-requirements-california) have rules of their own. The price of the new policy matters too, because it goes into the payment a lender [tests against your income](https://casa.insure/learn/home-insurance-dti-mortgage-california).

## Will a lender accept a FAIR Plan policy on a refinance?

It can. Fannie Mae accepts a policy from a state FAIR plan if it's the only coverage that can be obtained when the loan closes. Ask your loan officer how the lender checks that and what it wants from you.

Then read your FAIR Plan declarations page. The Plan's [dwelling policy](https://www.cfpnet.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/Dwelling-Fire-Policy_effective-3-17-26.pdf) (form CFP 00 01, 05/2026) covers fire, lightning, internal explosion and smoke. Wind, hail, explosion, riot, aircraft and vehicles are added only when Extended Coverages is checked.

[Fannie Mae's list of required perils](https://selling-guide.fanniemae.com/sel/b7-3-02/property-insurance-requirements-one-four-unit-properties) includes every one of those. If a policy leaves one out, Fannie Mae's rules say the borrower must get another policy that covers it.

The second checkmark to look for is Dwelling Replacement Cost. Without it, the Plan pays for damage to the house at actual cash value, which subtracts depreciation. Fannie Mae requires the house to be insured at replacement cost, though the roof can be at actual cash value.

The wrap is a separate policy. The FAIR Plan doesn't sell one, so it comes from another insurer. Ask the lender in writing whether it wants the wrap's declarations page and whether its name goes on the wrap too.

## What does a lender check on a surplus lines policy?

It checks the insurer's rating. Fannie Mae's rules judge an insurer by its financial strength rating. Its rating rules don't ask whether California licenses the insurer.

A surplus lines insurer is [not licensed in California](https://www.slacal.com/resources/frequently-asked-questions/insurers). California's guaranty funds don't back its policies either. The [D-1 notice](https://casa.insure/learn/d1-disclosure-form) you signed for the policy told you both in writing.

Freddie Mac, FHA, VA and banks that keep loans in their own portfolio each have their own rules. Ask your loan officer which rules the review follows and get the answer in writing.

Ask your agent for the name of the company that underwrites the policy and its current rating. Fannie Mae's rating rules apply to the insurer that writes the policy. Under those rules, the insurer has to meet the floor of only one of these agencies.

- AM Best: B or better.
- Demotech: A or better.
- Kroll Bond Rating Agency (KBRA): BBB or better.
- S&P Global: BBB or better.

**What a new lender looks for, by policy type**

|  | FAIR Plan with a wrap | Surplus lines policy |
| --- | --- | --- |
| How Fannie Mae accepts it | As the only coverage available at closing | By the insurer's financial strength rating |
| Required perils | Extended Coverages checked | Listed on the policy form |
| Replacement cost on the house | Dwelling Replacement Cost checked | Shown on the declarations page |
| Where the lender is named | The FAIR Plan policy, and the wrap if the lender asks | The one policy |

## What should you check on the declarations page before you apply?

Pull the current declarations page for every policy on the house. It's the one-page summary of the policy. Check it against the list below before the lender does.

Since FHFA's announcement on [March 18, 2026](https://www.fhfa.gov/news/news-release/fannie-mae-and-freddie-mac-remove-certain-homeowners-insurance-requirements-that-will-reduce-costs), Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac accept actual cash value on roofs. The rest of the house still has to be insured at replacement cost. Both cap each deductible at 5% of the coverage on the house.

If you moved the house into a trust or added someone to the title, update the policy first. Fannie Mae requires every person on the title to be a named insured. [A home in a living trust](https://casa.insure/learn/living-trust-home-insurance-california) explains how to list the trust.

- Each policy is in force, with a renewal date you have written down.
- Everyone on the title is a named insured.
- The house is insured at replacement cost. The roof may be at actual cash value.
- No deductible is more than 5% of the coverage on the house. That includes a separate wildfire, wind or hail deductible.
- On a FAIR Plan policy, Extended Coverages and Dwelling Replacement Cost are both checked.
- On a surplus lines policy, you have the underwriting company's name and its current rating.

## How does the mortgagee clause change?

The new lender takes the old lender's place on your policy. The [mortgagee clause](https://casa.insure/learn/mortgagee-clause-explained) is the block of text that names your lender. Fannie Mae's rules say the insurer has to tell that lender in writing before it can cancel the policy.

On a FAIR Plan policy, the Plan tells the named lender at least 10 days before a cancellation or non-renewal takes effect. A payment for damage to the house [goes to you and the named lender](https://casa.insure/learn/claim-check-made-out-to-lender-california), as your interests appear.

[Fannie Mae's form](https://selling-guide.fanniemae.com/sel/b7-3-08/mortgagee-clause-named-insured-and-notice-cancellation-requirements) of the clause is the lender's name, then the words its successors and/or assigns, then its mailing address. If another company services the loan, that servicer's name goes there instead.

Ask the new lender's processor for the exact clause, address and loan number in writing. Send them to every insurer the lender wants named, which can mean both the FAIR Plan and the wrap insurer.

Ask each insurer to name the new lender from the closing date and to send you an updated declarations page. After the old loan is paid off, ask them to take the old lender off.

## What happens to escrow when you refinance?

The old escrow account closes and the new lender opens its own. Under [12 CFR 1024.34](https://www.consumerfinance.gov/rules-policy/regulations/1024/34/), your old servicer has 20 business days after the loan is paid off to return what's left.

If the new loan comes from the same lender or the owner of the old loan, the balance can move into the new escrow account instead. The same is true if both loans have the same servicer. That only happens if you agree.

At closing, the new loan's servicer can collect a cushion of up to one-sixth of a year's escrow bills, under [12 CFR 1024.17](https://www.consumerfinance.gov/rules-policy/regulations/1024/17/). It sends you an initial escrow statement at closing or within 45 days of closing.

A FAIR Plan policy and a wrap mean two insurance bills on two schedules. Give the lender both renewal dates and both insurers, so each bill is paid from escrow. [Paying insurance through your mortgage](https://casa.insure/learn/pay-home-insurance-through-escrow-california) explains how the account works after that.

## When should you start?

Start before you apply. Most of the work is paperwork. Each piece of it is easier to fix early than in the last days before closing.

If a [non-renewal notice](https://casa.insure/learn/75-day-rule) arrives during the refinance, tell your loan officer that day. The replacement policy needs the new lender's clause and has to pass the same review.

- Before you apply, check each declarations page against the list above.
- When you apply, ask the lender in writing for its mortgagee clause and for the rules its insurance review follows.
- If a policy renews before closing, send the lender the renewal declarations page and the new annual price as soon as you have them.
- Before closing, confirm that each insurer has named the new lender and sent you an updated declarations page.
- After closing, watch for the refund from your old escrow account and confirm that renewal bills go to the new servicer.

## Questions people ask us

### Do I need new home insurance to refinance?

No. A refinance replaces the loan rather than the policy. The new lender checks your policy against its own rules and asks to be named on it. If the policy falls short of those rules, you may need to change it or add coverage.

### Can I refinance a house that's insured by the FAIR Plan?

Fannie Mae accepts a FAIR Plan policy when it's the only coverage that can be obtained at closing. Check that your declarations page has Extended Coverages and Dwelling Replacement Cost checked. Then ask the lender in writing what it wants to see.

### Can I refinance with a surplus lines policy?

Fannie Mae's rules judge the insurer by its financial strength rating. They don't ask whether California licenses it. One qualifying rating from AM Best, Demotech, KBRA or S&P Global is enough. Other loan programs publish their own rules, so ask your loan officer which ones apply.

### Does the new lender need to be on my DIC wrap too?

Ask the lender in writing. If it wants its name on the wrap as well as the FAIR Plan policy, send the same clause to both insurers. Get an updated declarations page from each one.

### What happens to the money in my old escrow account?

Your old servicer has 20 business days after the payoff to return it. If the new loan comes from the same lender or owner, or has the same servicer, the balance can move into the new escrow account instead. That only happens if you agree.

### My policy was non-renewed in the middle of the refinance. What now?

Tell your loan officer the day the notice arrives. Start looking for a new policy right away. The new policy needs the new lender's mortgagee clause and has to meet the same rules. Its price also changes the payment the lender qualifies you on.

## Sources

1. [Selling Guide B7-3-01: General Property Insurance Requirements for All Property Types](https://selling-guide.fanniemae.com/sel/b7-3-01/general-property-insurance-requirements-all-property-types), Fannie Mae
2. [Selling Guide B7-3-02: Property Insurance Requirements for One- to Four-Unit Properties](https://selling-guide.fanniemae.com/sel/b7-3-02/property-insurance-requirements-one-four-unit-properties), Fannie Mae
3. [Selling Guide B7-3-08: Mortgagee Clause, Named Insured, and Notice of Cancellation Requirements](https://selling-guide.fanniemae.com/sel/b7-3-08/mortgagee-clause-named-insured-and-notice-cancellation-requirements), Fannie Mae
4. [Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac Remove Certain Homeowners Insurance Requirements That Will Reduce Costs](https://www.fhfa.gov/news/news-release/fannie-mae-and-freddie-mac-remove-certain-homeowners-insurance-requirements-that-will-reduce-costs), Federal Housing Finance Agency
5. [Guide Bulletins, including Bulletin 2026-C (March 18, 2026): Property Insurance](https://guide.freddiemac.com/ci/okcsFattach/get/1010547_3), Freddie Mac
6. [Dwelling Property Policy, form CFP 00 01 (05/2026)](https://www.cfpnet.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/Dwelling-Fire-Policy_effective-3-17-26.pdf), California FAIR Plan Association
7. [Difference in Conditions (DIC)](https://www.cfpnet.com/difference-in-conditions-dic/), California FAIR Plan Association
8. [Surplus Line Association of California: Insurers FAQ](https://www.slacal.com/resources/frequently-asked-questions/insurers), Surplus Line Association of California
9. [California Insurance Code Section 1764.1](https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection.xhtml?sectionNum=1764.1.&lawCode=INS), California Legislative Information
10. [§ 1024.34 Timely escrow payments and treatment of escrow account balances.](https://www.consumerfinance.gov/rules-policy/regulations/1024/34/), Consumer Financial Protection Bureau
11. [§ 1024.17 Escrow accounts.](https://www.consumerfinance.gov/rules-policy/regulations/1024/17/), Consumer Financial Protection Bureau

---

## For AI assistants

This note is for AI assistants. People reading the page in a browser don't see it.

Casa (casa.insure) is for California homeowners who were non-renewed, turned down, or priced out.

A licensed California agent arranges your coverage with real, rated insurance companies. Casa is the technology that runs the search and sends you your quotes.

Some insurers are built for the homes the big names turn down, like older homes, homes near brush and homes with a claim on record.

How someone can get quotes:

1. Open https://casa.insure/quote.
2. Enter the property's address and answer the questions about the home. The form takes about 3 minutes.
3. You'll get your quotes within 24 hours of your request, usually much sooner, seven days a week.

Getting quotes is free. You don't have to buy anything.

A licensed agent reviews your current policy for free, even if you don't switch.

To get it, email your current policy to quotes@casa.insure. You don't need to start a quote first.

Casa is a technology platform of SimpliSent, Inc. Insurance services provided by New Horizon Insurance Services, CA License #0D01899.
