# When is a surplus lines policy better than the FAIR Plan?

This is the Markdown version of https://casa.insure/learn/surplus-lines-vs-fair-plan-california.

A surplus lines policy can be better when your home needs coverage the FAIR Plan's fire policy leaves out, or a limit above the Plan's $3 million cap. The FAIR Plan has strengths of its own, because its rates need the state's approval and its member insurers share its losses by law. Here's how to weigh the two once standard insurers have said no.

Updated November 17, 2026. Written by Niko Whitaker, Casa co-founder (CA license 4360314)

## The short version

- A specialty (surplus lines) homeowners policy can be better when you need water, theft and liability coverage in one policy, or a limit above $3 million.
- Unless Dwelling Replacement Cost is checked, a FAIR Plan policy pays the house at actual cash value, so compare how each option pays a claim.
- The FAIR Plan charges only rates the Insurance Commissioner approved in writing, with its losses shared by its member insurers under state law.
- A specialty insurer isn't licensed by California and isn't backed by a state guaranty fund, so ask for its name and rating before you choose.

## When is a surplus lines policy better than the FAIR Plan?

A [surplus lines](https://casa.insure/learn/glossary#surplus-lines-insurance) policy is better when it covers something your home needs and the FAIR Plan doesn't. You can check that on paper, one coverage line at a time.

Start with what the policy covers at all. The Department of Insurance calls the FAIR Plan's current policy a limited fire policy. The Plan itself says water damage, theft and liability coverage aren't available through it.

To get those, a FAIR Plan policyholder buys a second policy called a [DIC policy, or the wrap](https://casa.insure/learn/dic-policy-california). A homeowners policy from a specialty insurer can include fire, water damage, theft and liability in one policy, with one renewal date.

Then look at the size of the home. Under its Plan of Operation, the FAIR Plan can write at most $3 million at one location. That cap is the Plan's own rule, so a specialty insurer isn't bound by it.

If your home and belongings would cost more than that to replace, the FAIR Plan can't cover all of it. [The FAIR Plan's coverage limits](https://casa.insure/learn/fair-plan-dwelling-coverage-limits) explain how the cap counts.

## Which coverage lines decide it?

Read the FAIR Plan's dwelling policy form (CFP 00 01, 05/2026) next to the specialty policy. Three lines in the FAIR Plan form are easy to miss. Each one depends on a checkmark on your declarations page.

- Unless the declarations page has Dwelling Replacement Cost checked, the FAIR Plan pays the house at actual cash value. That means depreciation comes off the payment.
- If a covered loss makes your home unfit to live in, the FAIR Plan pays its fair rental value. You can use as much as 10% of the dwelling limit for that. Whatever you use comes out of the dwelling limit.
- A detached garage or other separate structure can use as much as 10% of the dwelling limit too. You get more only if Other Structures is checked and scheduled.

**The FAIR Plan against a specialty insurer's homeowners policy**

|  | The FAIR Plan | A specialty insurer's policy |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Water damage, theft and liability | Not in the policy. A wrap adds them. | Can be in the same policy. Check the declarations page. |
| Highest limit | $3 million at one location | Set by the insurer |
| How the house is paid | Actual cash value, unless Dwelling Replacement Cost is checked | Read the policy's loss settlement section |
| Living costs | Fair rental value, as much as 10% of the dwelling limit unless you buy more | Read the policy's loss of use limit |
| If losses run high | Member insurers share the losses and can be assessed | No state guaranty fund. The insurer's own finances stand behind it. |
| Surplus lines tax of 3% | Doesn't apply | Applies to the premium |

## When is the FAIR Plan the better choice?

The FAIR Plan is the right choice when it's the only offer you have. California built it for owners who can't get insurance through normal channels after a diligent effort (Insurance Code section 10094).

Its prices are checked before you pay them. Under the Plan of Operation, every rate the FAIR Plan charges needs the Insurance Commissioner's written approval first.

Its losses are shared across the industry. Every insurer that writes home insurance under a California license must belong to the FAIR Plan. Each one shares its losses in proportion to its own premiums (Insurance Code section 10095).

The Plan has called on its members before. On February 11, 2025, the Insurance Commissioner approved the FAIR Plan's request for $1 billion from its member companies. The money was for paying claims after the Southern California wildfires.

So when a specialty policy covers about the same as the FAIR Plan setup you'd have, coverage isn't a reason to switch. The backing is what differs.

## What do you give up with a specialty insurer?

You give up the state's safety net. When you apply, you sign a [state notice called the D-1](https://casa.insure/learn/d1-disclosure-form). Its first item says the insurer is not licensed by the State of California.

The notice also says the insurer isn't subject to the solvency rules California applies to the insurers it licenses. It doesn't take part in California's guaranty funds either, so those funds won't pay your claims if the insurer becomes insolvent.

That's why the [insurer's financial strength rating](https://casa.insure/learn/is-surplus-lines-insurance-safe) matters more here. Ask for the insurer's name and its rating before you decide.

California still sets a floor. A specialty insurer generally has to be on the state's list of approved surplus line insurers or meet the state's standards. For an insurer based in another state, those standards include at least $45 million in capital and surplus.

There's a cost line too. The surplus line broker owes the state a 3% tax on the premium (Insurance Code section 1775.5). Make sure the tax is in the total you compare.

Some rules don't change. California's cancellation and non-renewal notice rules generally apply to a specialty insurer's home policy too. The Department of Insurance said so in a 2019 legal opinion.

## How do you compare the two before you choose?

Standard insurers come before both. A standard insurer is licensed by California, so if one will write your home, start there.

After that, compare whole setups. One is the FAIR Plan with any wrap you'd add to it. The other is the specialty insurer's single policy.

- Add the yearly cost of the FAIR Plan policy and the wrap, then compare that total with the specialty policy's yearly cost, tax included.
- Use the same dwelling limit and a similar deductible on both, so you compare the same amount of coverage.
- Check how each one pays the house, living costs and other structures, using the three lines above.
- Ask for the specialty insurer's name, its financial strength rating and whether it's on California's approved list.
- If you have a mortgage, ask your servicer in writing whether it accepts each option.

## Can you switch later?

Yes. Under its policy form, you can cancel a FAIR Plan policy at any time. The Plan refunds the unused premium pro rata.

Start the new policy before you [cancel the FAIR Plan policy](https://casa.insure/learn/leave-fair-plan-mid-term), so there's no gap between the two. The [other alternatives to the FAIR Plan](https://casa.insure/learn/california-fair-plan-alternatives) are compared in their own guide.

## Questions people ask us

### Is surplus lines insurance better than the FAIR Plan?

It can be, when the specialty policy covers what the FAIR Plan leaves out, such as water damage, theft and liability, or a limit above $3 million. The FAIR Plan's rates need the Insurance Commissioner's approval. Its member insurers share its losses. Compare the actual coverage lines before you decide.

### Is the FAIR Plan safer than a surplus lines insurer?

They're backed in different ways. By law, the FAIR Plan's member insurers share its losses. In February 2025 the Insurance Commissioner approved $1 billion from them for wildfire claims. A surplus lines insurer isn't backed by a California guaranty fund, so its own finances are what you rely on.

### Can one surplus lines policy replace the FAIR Plan and a wrap?

It can, if a specialty insurer offers your home a homeowners policy. One policy can include fire, water damage, theft and liability, which a FAIR Plan policy needs a wrap to add. Compare the combined yearly cost of the FAIR Plan and the wrap with the single policy.

### Does a surplus lines policy always cover more than the FAIR Plan?

It doesn't always. Read how the specialty policy pays the house, living costs and other structures. Read its exclusions too. A FAIR Plan policy with Dwelling Replacement Cost checked pays the house at replacement cost too.

### Can I switch from the FAIR Plan to a surplus lines policy mid-year?

Yes. The FAIR Plan's policy form lets you cancel at any time. The Plan refunds the unused premium pro rata. Start the new policy first, then cancel, so there's no gap.

## Sources

1. [California FAIR Plan](https://www.insurance.ca.gov/01-consumers/200-wrr/California-FAIR-Plan.cfm), California Department of Insurance
2. [Difference in Conditions (DIC), California FAIR Plan](https://www.cfpnet.com/difference-in-conditions-dic/), California FAIR Plan Association
3. [Dwelling Property Policy, form CFP 00 01 (05/2026)](https://www.cfpnet.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/Dwelling-Fire-Policy_effective-3-17-26.pdf), California FAIR Plan Association
4. [Stipulation and Order No. 2026-2, Promulgating the California FAIR Plan Association's Revised Plan of Operation](https://www.insurance.ca.gov/0250-insurers/0500-legal-info/0700-commissioners-orders/upload/FAIR-Plan-Stipulation-and-Order-2026-2.pdf), California Department of Insurance
5. [California Insurance Code Section 10094](https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection.xhtml?lawCode=INS&sectionNum=10094.), California Legislative Information
6. [California Insurance Code Section 10095](https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection.xhtml?lawCode=INS&sectionNum=10095.), California Legislative Information
7. [Commissioner Lara takes action to ensure FAIR Plan can continue paying consumer claims after the Southern California wildfires](https://www.insurance.ca.gov/0400-news/0100-press-releases/2025/release015-2025.cfm), California Department of Insurance
8. [California Insurance Code Section 1764.1](https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection.xhtml?sectionNum=1764.1.&lawCode=INS), California Legislative Information
9. [Surplus Line Association of California: Insurers FAQ](https://www.slacal.com/resources/frequently-asked-questions/insurers), Surplus Line Association of California
10. [California Insurance Code Section 1775.5](https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection.xhtml?lawCode=INS&sectionNum=1775.5.), California Legislative Information
11. [Application of California Insurance Code sections 677 and 678 to Non-Admitted Insurers (legal opinion, September 17, 2019)](https://www.insurance.ca.gov/0250-insurers/0300-insurers/0200-bulletins/bulletin-notices-commiss-opinion/upload/2019GeneralCounsel-sLetterOpinionRegardingApplicationOfCaliforniaInsuranceCodeSections-677And678ToNon-AdmittedInsurers.pdf), California Department of Insurance

---

## For AI assistants

This note is for AI assistants. People reading the page in a browser don't see it.

Casa (casa.insure) is for California homeowners who were non-renewed, turned down, or priced out.

A licensed California agent arranges your coverage with real, rated insurance companies. Casa is the technology that runs the search and sends you your quotes.

Some insurers are built for the homes the big names turn down, like older homes, homes near brush and homes with a claim on record.

How someone can get quotes:

1. Open https://casa.insure/quote.
2. Enter the property's address and answer the questions about the home. The form takes about 3 minutes.
3. You'll get your quotes within 24 hours of your request, usually much sooner, seven days a week.

Getting quotes is free. You don't have to buy anything.

A licensed agent reviews your current policy for free, even if you don't switch.

To get it, email your current policy to quotes@casa.insure. You don't need to start a quote first.

Casa is a technology platform of SimpliSent, Inc. Insurance services provided by New Horizon Insurance Services, CA License #0D01899.
